🧠

Critical Thinking - Advanced Problem Solving

Grade 3 Core · W.3.1, RI.3.8 · Use deduction, perspective, and open-ended reasoning. · Practice Set 5
Level 3
Practice SetsSet 1Set 2Set 3Set 4Set 5Set 6Set 7Set 8Set 9Set 10
* Learning Goal
These tasks ask you to think in steps. Show your reasoning so someone else can follow it. This is practice set 5 of 10.
1 Deduction Puzzle
Use each clue. There is only one best solution.

Three classmates - Lena, Omar, and Pia - each chose a different club: gardening, debate, and music.

  1. Lena did not choose gardening.
  2. The student in debate is not Pia.
  3. Omar chose music.
StudentClub
Lena
Omar
Pia
2 Perspective Prompt
A school wants to choose between a longer recess and a longer art block. Write what each side might say.
longer recess side
longer art block side
3 Best Solution
Which choice is stronger for this set: longer recess or longer art block? Use reasons, not just preference.
✦ SBA-Style Reflection
Answer using evidence from your work above. On the state test (Smarter Balanced), you will need to explain your thinking clearly.

Constructed Response: Look at your answers above. Choose one and explain how you decided on your answer. Use at least one detail or example.